Skip to content
RESEARCH-BASED GUIDES. PRACTICAL EVERYDAY ADVICE.How we pick products
RTReviewstookA clearer perspective
Printers

HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 vs Brother MFC-L2820DW: Inkjet or Laser?

HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 vs Brother MFC-L2820DW compared from listings: color vs monochrome, speed, feeder, fax and connectivity.

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. How we pick products

Where to buy

Check the latest price, availability and delivery on Amazon. Orders are placed on Amazon. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

Read the full guide ↓

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, reviewstook.com earns from qualifying purchases. Links to Amazon on this page are affiliate links; they cost you nothing extra.

Quick answer: Both are fax-capable all-in-ones for offices. The OfficeJet Pro 9125 prints in color on an inkjet; the MFC-L2820DW is a monochrome laser with a larger 50-page document feeder and a listed 36 ppm print speed.

This comparison is built from the product listings and manufacturer information on Amazon, not our own testing. Confirm details on the product pages before you buy.

By the Reviewstook Editorial Team. Last updated: October 31, 2026.

Visual summary: Color; Speed and feeder; Ink policy.
Visual summary of this guide. Read the article for full details and qualifications.

At a Glance

Feature HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 Brother MFC-L2820DW
Type Color inkjet all-in-one Monochrome laser all-in-one
Fax Yes Yes
Auto two-sided printing Yes (and scanning) Yes
Document feeder Yes 50 pages
Tray 250 sheets Not stated here
Touchscreen 2.7-inch 2.7-inch with cloud apps
Connections (listing) Dual-band Wi-Fi Dual-band Wi-Fi, Ethernet, USB
Supplies HP ink, Instant Ink trial Brother TN830 / TN830XL toner
In this guide

Key Differences

Color

The 9125 prints in color. The MFC-L2820DW prints black and white only.

Speed and feeder

The Brother lists up to 36 ppm and a 50-page feeder.

Ink policy

HP printers may restrict third-party cartridges; read the policy.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 if

you need color documents, brochures or presentations.

Check on Amazon

Choose the Brother MFC-L2820DW if — hp officejet pro 9125 vs brother mfc-l2820dw: inkjet or laser?

Choose the Brother MFC-L2820DW if

your work is mostly black-and-white and you want laser speed and a bigger feeder.

Brother MFC-L2820DW Wireless Compact Monochrome All-in-One Laser Printer with Copy
Brother MFC-L2820DW Wireless Compact Monochrome All-in-One Laser Printer with Copy

Check on Amazon

What the Differences Mean

A spec table shows what differs. This section explains why each difference matters.

Lasers are quick and sharp for text; inkjets handle color and photos better; ink tank models cost less to run. Choose by what you print most. Here, HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 lists “Color inkjet all-in-one” while Brother MFC-L2820DW lists “Monochrome laser all-in-one”.

Duplex printing

Automatic duplex saves paper and flipping. Check whether it covers printing only or also copying. Here, HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 lists “Yes (and scanning)” while Brother MFC-L2820DW lists “Yes”.

Scan and copy features

A document feeder helps with multi-page jobs and duplex scanning saves time. If you rarely scan, a flatbed is enough. Here, HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 lists “Yes” while Brother MFC-L2820DW lists “50 pages”.

Paper handling

Tray size sets how often you refill. Check supported sizes and media types such as envelopes and labels. Here, HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 lists “250 sheets” while Brother MFC-L2820DW lists “Not stated here”.

Connection

How a printer connects affects setup and reliability. Wi-Fi is convenient for sharing, USB is the most dependable, and Ethernet suits offices. Check the Wi-Fi band and AirPrint or Mopria support. Here, HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 lists “Dual-band Wi-Fi” while Brother MFC-L2820DW lists “Dual-band Wi-Fi, Ethernet, USB”.

Which Is Right for Which Buyer

  • If you print rarely, a low-cost model with cheap or long-life ink or toner avoids waste from dried ink.
  • If you print a lot, prioritize a low cost per page, such as an ink tank or laser model.
  • If you need to scan or copy documents, check for a document feeder.
  • If you print photos, check the number of inks and paper support.

Before You Buy: A Five-Point Check

  • Confirm the exact model on the product page; similar names often hide different features.
  • Check the cost of replacement ink or toner.
  • Check the Wi-Fi band and mobile printing support.
  • Check the size of the printer against your space.
  • Check the return window and warranty.

This comparison is based on the Amazon listings and manufacturer information, not our own testing. Treat it as a way to narrow the choice, then confirm the details that matter to you.

Inkjet or Laser: The Core Trade-Offs

This comparison is really about two printing technologies. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 is an inkjet that prints in color. The Brother MFC-L2820DW is a monochrome laser that uses toner. Choosing between them starts with what your office prints.

Color matters when you produce marketing handouts, charts, proposals with branding or photos. An inkjet can handle these, and it can also print text. A monochrome laser is a fine choice if nearly everything is black text: reports, invoices, contracts and forms. It cannot print color at all, so if you need color even occasionally, plan for an outside print service.

There are other differences in how each type behaves. Inkjets use liquid ink and may need cleaning cycles, especially if idle for long periods. Lasers use toner and tend to be less sensitive to idle periods. Print speeds, page costs and paper handling also differ by model, so use the listing information rather than assumptions about the technology.

  • Mostly text, steady volume: laser is a natural fit.
  • Color needed in-house: inkjet is the one that can do it.
  • Mixed use: consider how often color is truly needed.

Write down your typical weekly jobs before deciding, and mark those that must be in color.

Document Feeder and Fax in a Working Office

Both models are described as fax-capable all-in-ones. If fax is a real part of your workflow, confirm what that means for each one. Fax features generally need a phone line connection at the printer, and setup is covered in the manual. Look at whether you need to send, receive, or both, and whether you need to store or forward received faxes.

The Brother listing highlights a 50-page document feeder, and the HP lists a feeder as well. A feeder is useful when you copy or scan multi-page paperwork. Check the listing for what the feeder supports, including two-sided scanning, and for paper limits. A larger feeder helps for long documents, but each page still needs to be in good condition for reliable feeding.

Consider routine office tasks. Scanning client documents to a folder, copying forms, and sending a signed page by email are common. Look for scan-to-email, scan-to-network folder or scan-to-cloud features in the listing, and confirm which ones need setup on your network.

  • Remove staples, clips and sticky notes before using the feeder.
  • Use the glass for fragile, folded or odd-sized originals.
  • Find out whether fax needs a dedicated line in your office.

If you rarely use fax, choose on the basis of the printing itself rather than fax features.

Supplies and Running Cost Planning for an Office

Running costs usually matter more than the purchase price in an office. The first step is to find the supplies each printer uses: ink cartridges for the HP, toner (and possibly a drum) for the Brother. Look up the cartridge names, the size options and the page yields that the maker states, and keep in mind that yields are estimates.

The post notes an ink policy for the HP, so check the listing and the maker’s information about which cartridges are supported and how the printer treats other supplies. For the Brother, check its toner policy in the same way. Policies and firmware behavior can change, so check the current product pages.

Compare cost per page using the cartridge price divided by the stated yield, and remember that color and black are priced differently on an inkjet. Printing mostly black text will use one supply, while mixed color work uses several. Also consider how often you must replace supplies, since an interruption in a busy day costs time.

  • Keep a spare of the supply you use most.
  • Track pages printed per month.
  • Check subscription or auto-delivery programs and read their terms.
  • Recycle used cartridges as the maker instructs.

Also include paper in your calculation, since two-sided printing and draft modes reduce its use.

Networking, Sharing and Keeping It Secure

The Brother listing shows dual-band Wi-Fi, Ethernet and USB, while the HP listing in this comparison shows dual-band Wi-Fi. If your office has a wired network, check whether the printer you prefer can connect by cable. A wired connection is often steadier when several people print.

Consider how many users and devices will print. Check the list of supported operating systems, mobile printing options and whether drivers are needed. In a mixed office with Windows, Mac and phones, confirm each is supported.

Security deserves a few minutes. Change any default administrator password, keep the firmware up to date, and avoid making the printer’s web page reachable from the internet. If the printer stores scanned documents or address books, learn how to clear them before you sell or retire the device.

  • Choose a fixed address or router reservation for the printer.
  • Use a strong administrator password.
  • Review who can send jobs to the printer.
  • Check the manual for secure print or user authentication options.

Place the printer where people can reach it, with room to open covers and clear paper jams. Ventilation and a stable surface also help it last longer.

Which Office Printer Should You Buy: HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 or Brother MFC-L2820DW?

Buy the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 if your office needs color, and the Brother MFC-L2820DW if nearly everything you print is black text. Everything else in this comparison is a refinement of that one decision.

Use the pairings below as a quick way to match your situation to a model. They rely only on what the post already states about each printer and on general knowledge of inkjet and laser machines.

  • Client proposals, flyers, charts and presentations: go for the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125, because the Brother cannot print color at all.
  • Invoices, contracts, forms and reports in black and white: choose the Brother MFC-L2820DW, a monochrome laser built around text.
  • Several people printing on a wired network: the Brother listing shows Ethernet, so it fits that setup more clearly than the HP listing used here.
  • Long stacks of paperwork to scan or copy: the Brother is described with a larger document feeder, so it is the natural first look.
  • A mix of color and text with moderate volume: the HP covers both jobs in one machine, which avoids a second device.
  • Occasional printing with long gaps: lasers are often less sensitive to idle periods, so the Brother may be less fussy, but confirm the maker’s guidance.

If you are still split, count how many pages each week truly need color. If the answer is almost none, the laser is the simpler fit. If the answer is a regular share, the inkjet saves you trips to a print shop.

A laser such as the Brother MFC-L2820DW is generally known for crisp black text, while an inkjet such as the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 is the one that produces color, and it can print text as well. The difference you notice depends on what you print and on which paper you load.

For everyday documents, both can look professional. Where they separate is in the details of the finished page, and these points are worth thinking about before you buy.

  • Small text and fine lines: lasers tend to produce sharp edges on plain paper, which suits spreadsheets and legal documents.
  • Color charts and branded handouts: only the HP can produce them, and results improve when you use paper meant for the job.
  • Handling after printing: toner output is usually dry when it leaves the machine, while liquid ink may need a moment, and some inks can smear if a page gets wet. Check the maker’s notes on the ink type.
  • Paper choice: inkjets can respond noticeably to paper quality, so test a small pack of your usual stock before you buy a large supply.

Photo quality is a separate topic. If photographs matter, treat the HP as the starting point and read the listing for supported photo paper. A monochrome laser cannot print photos in color, so it is the wrong tool for that job.

Both printers offer automatic two-sided printing according to the table, which cuts paper use and makes longer documents easier to handle. Look at whether the finished sheets curl or show show-through on thinner paper, and adjust your stock if they do.

What to Check on the Listing Before You Buy an Office All-in-One

Before you click through, confirm the exact model, what is in the box, and what the printer needs from your space and network. Similar model names often hide different features, so read the listing rather than relying on memory.

  • Exact model name: confirm it matches the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 or the Brother MFC-L2820DW you meant to buy.
  • Starter supplies: find out whether the cartridges or toner in the box are full size or smaller starter units, since that affects how soon you reorder.
  • Trial programs: the HP listing mentions an Instant Ink trial. Read its terms, including what happens when the trial ends.
  • Supply names: note the cartridge or toner names, including the higher-yield option for the Brother, so you can compare running costs.
  • Fax setup: confirm whether you have a phone line available at the printer, because fax generally needs one.
  • Footprint: measure the shelf or desk, and leave room to open the scanner lid, the covers and the paper tray.
  • Operating systems: check support for your Windows, Mac and mobile devices.
  • Warranty and returns: check the return window and warranty terms shown on the listing, and keep the packaging while you test it.

When the unit arrives, run the basics straight away: a text page, a color page if relevant, a copy from the feeder, a scan to your computer and a test fax if you plan to use it. Problems found in the first days are far easier to resolve than ones found months later.

Setup, Care and Troubleshooting for a Busy Office Printer

A little routine care keeps either printer reliable. Most office printer problems come from paper, dust and neglected supplies, not from the machine itself.

Start with paper. Fan the sheets, keep them dry and flat, and do not overfill the tray. Mixed paper types and damp paper are common causes of jams and double feeds. Match the paper size and type in the printer settings to what you actually loaded.

For an inkjet, run the maker’s cleaning or alignment routine only when print quality drops, since each cycle uses ink. Print something now and then if the machine would otherwise sit idle for weeks. For a laser, avoid pulling jammed paper roughly, follow the jam path in the manual, and let the maker’s instructions guide any cleaning near the toner and drum area.

Keep the scanner glass and feeder rollers clean. Streaks on scans or copies are often just dust or a mark on the glass. A soft, lint-free cloth is usually enough, but follow the manual for cleaning products.

  • Update firmware from the maker’s official support page.
  • Keep a small log of error messages and fixes.
  • Store spare supplies flat and out of heat and direct sun.
  • Do not use the feeder for damaged or curled originals.

If errors persist after cleaning and a restart, contact the maker’s support while you are still inside the warranty period.

What Are the Downsides, and Who Should Skip Each Printer?

Each model has a trade-off that matters for certain buyers. Knowing it in advance is better than discovering it after setup.

Who should skip the Brother MFC-L2820DW: anyone who needs color, even occasionally, for client material. It prints black and white only, so a color job means an outside service or a second printer.

Who should skip the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125: offices that print mostly plain black text in large batches and want the simplicity of toner. Also read the ink policy carefully, since the post notes that HP printers may restrict third-party cartridges. If you want freedom to choose supplies, confirm what is supported before you commit.

Is paying more for a bigger feeder or extra features worth it? Only if you will use them. A large feeder saves real time for people who scan stacks of paperwork every week, but it adds little for someone who copies a single page now and then. Fax is the same: it is valuable in some workflows and an unused feature in others.

Is a cheaper printer enough? For light use, a simpler model can serve well. The reason to step up to an all-in-one like these is the combination of fax, scanning with a feeder, two-sided printing and network features in a single device.

Be honest about your volume and your color needs. Those two answers do most of the work in choosing between these printers.

Compare the two models above, check the current listing for supply names and what is included, then choose the one that matches your weekly print mix and use the button for that model.

A Week of Ordinary Printing: How the Choice Shows Up Day to Day

Specifications tell you what HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 and Brother MFC-L2820DW can do on their best day. What decides whether you stay happy with either one is a much more ordinary question: how it behaves across a normal week of mixed jobs, interruptions and small annoyances. Walking through a realistic week is a useful way to test the decision before you commit, because the differences that matter most rarely appear in a single test page.

Monday usually starts with documents. School forms, invoices, shipping paperwork, a contract that needs a signature and a scan to send back. Jobs like these reward a printer that wakes quickly, feeds paper without drama and produces text that stays sharp when the page is photocopied again later. With either machine, the habit that helps most is unglamorous: keep the paper tray loaded with the stock you use most, keep a small stack of envelopes or labels separate rather than mixed into the tray, and let the printer finish its alignment and registration routines after setup instead of skipping them in a hurry. Rushed setup is the single most common cause of crooked scans and offset margins that owners then blame on the hardware.

Midweek is when households discover their real color habits. A worksheet with colored diagrams, a presentation printed for rehearsal, photos for a school project, a recipe with pictures. Color jobs expose how a printer handles coverage: heavy color blocks use far more ink or toner than a page of text, and they dry or fuse more slowly, so grabbing pages the instant they land can smudge or offset the image. Build in a few seconds of patience on dense color work and check the driver setting matches the paper actually loaded. Choosing a photo or matte setting while plain paper sits in the tray is a quiet way to waste supplies and get dull results from a perfectly capable machine, whichever of these two you own.

By Friday the pattern that separates the two models becomes practical rather than theoretical. If your week was mostly text with occasional color, running cost and standby behavior dominate: a machine that sips power while idle and does not demand attention between jobs fades into the background, which is exactly what most people want. If your week involved multi-page handouts, copying a stapled packet, or scanning a stack of receipts, feeder capacity, scan workflow and how the software names and files documents matter more than any headline speed figure. Neither HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 nor Brother MFC-L2820DW can change the shape of your week; the right choice is simply the one whose strengths line up with the jobs you actually repeated.

A small experiment worth running in the first week

During the first week, keep a simple tally on a sticky note: how many pages were plain text, how many had meaningful color, how many were copies or scans, and how many times you wished for a feature the printer does not have, such as a feeder, a bigger tray or a wired connection. That tally is more valuable than any review, because it tells you whether you bought the right category of machine. If the wish list stays empty, you chose well and can stop second-guessing. If one wish appears again and again, you have learned something precise about your next purchase, and you have learned it while the return window may still be open.

The same tally settles arguments between two close models better than specifications can. Two printers can look identical on paper and still suit different homes, because homes differ in the ratio of text to color, in how often anyone scans, and in whether printing happens in steady daily use or in occasional bursts separated by quiet weeks. Bursty use is harder on some technologies than steady use, a point the care section below takes up in detail.

Troubleshooting the Problems Owners Actually Meet

Most problems with a modern office all-in-one are not failures. They are mismatches between a setting, a supply or a habit and what the machine was asked to do. Working through the common ones in a sensible order saves a great deal of frustration, and the order matters: check the simple physical causes first, then the software causes, and only then suspect the hardware.

Faded, streaky or off-color output

Start with the paper path and the supply levels the machine itself reports, not the levels you assume are left. A partly empty supply can produce output that looks like a mechanical fault. Next, run the built-in maintenance or cleaning utility once, print the diagnostic page the utility offers, and look at which color or which area of the page is affected. A problem confined to one color points to a supply or a single channel; a problem repeated at the same position down every page points to something on the paper path, such as a dirty roller or a piece of debris. Repeating defects at regular intervals are a classic clue, because the spacing often matches the circumference of a roller or drum inside the machine.

Resist the urge to run cleaning cycles back to back. Each cycle consumes supplies, and several in a row can flood or overheat components that then need rest before output recovers. One cycle, a diagnostic page, a pause, and a fresh look will tell you more than five cycles in a row. If output improves but does not fully recover, check that the paper type setting matches the loaded stock and that the stack is not damp, overfilled or fanned poorly. Paper that has sat in a humid room feeds badly and accepts ink or toner unevenly, and it imitates several more serious faults.

Paper jams and misfeeds

Turn the machine off, open the access points the manual identifies, and remove paper by pulling in the direction of normal travel where possible, using both hands so the sheet does not tear. A torn fragment left inside will cause the next jam and the next. Once clear, inspect the stack you are about to reload: mixed sizes, curled edges and a tray filled past its marker all cause repeat misfeeds. Fan the stack, align it against the guides, and set the guides snug rather than tight. Guides squeezed too firmly bow the stack; guides left loose let sheets skew, which the machine may report as a jam even when nothing is stuck.

Connection dropouts

Wireless printing problems with either HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 or Brother MFC-L2820DW usually trace back to the network rather than the printer. A printer that worked at setup and later vanishes from the list of available devices has often been given a new address by the router, or the router has steered it to a band it handles poorly. Restarting the router and the printer in that order resolves a surprising share of cases. If dropouts persist, placing the printer where it has a clear signal path, rather than inside a closed cabinet or behind a metal filing cabinet, is a more durable fix than repeatedly reinstalling drivers. Where the option exists, reserving a fixed address for the printer in the router settings prevents the disappearing-printer problem from returning every few weeks.

Finally, keep the manual and the maker’s support pages as the authority for anything involving opening covers beyond the normal access points, replacing internal parts, or messages that mention service. The steps above cover the everyday layer of problems that owners can safely solve. A fault that survives new supplies, correct settings, a clean paper path and a stable network connection is a support conversation, and describing the steps you have already tried will get you to a useful answer much faster.

A Simple Care Routine That Prevents Most Problems

Printers rarely fail suddenly. They drift: output gets a little lighter, feeds get a little less reliable, scans pick up a line that was not there before. A light, regular care routine for your office all-in-one catches that drift early, when the fix is a wipe, a setting or a fresh supply rather than a repair. The routine below is deliberately modest, because a routine you actually follow beats an elaborate one you abandon.

Weekly: two minutes

Wipe the exterior and the scanner glass with a soft, dry or barely damp cloth. Scanner glass deserves special attention: a single fingerprint or speck of correction fluid on the glass becomes a line down every scan and copy, always in the same place, and owners often chase it as an ink or toner problem. If your machine has a document feeder, wipe the narrow glass strip the feeder reads from as well, since that strip is where feeder lines come from. Check the paper in the tray: remove curled or damp sheets, top up before the stack runs so low that the last sheets feed at an angle, and glance at the supply levels the machine reports so a low supplies never ambushes an urgent job.

Monthly: ten minutes

Print one page that exercises the whole machine: a document with text, a block of each color if it is a color machine, and a gray area. Look at it properly rather than glancing. Even coverage, clean edges and no repeating marks mean the machine is healthy. Run the alignment or calibration utility the maker provides if text looks fuzzy or colors outline the shapes they should fill. Open the paper path and look for dust and paper fragments, especially after any jam. Check for firmware and driver updates from the maker’s site, and read what an update changes before applying it; updates that mention feed reliability, network stability or scan quality are usually worth having, while nothing about an update should be applied in the middle of a deadline if the machine is working well.

Quarterly: a short review

Step back and look at the supplies picture. Are you replacing supplies far sooner than the yield figures in the listing suggested? Yield figures assume a standard page with modest coverage, so heavy color, dense graphics and frequent cleaning cycles all shorten real life. That is not a defect, but it is information: it may change which supply size is economical to buy, or whether your next machine should be a different category altogether. Also review where scans are being filed and whether the naming pattern still makes sense, clear the backlog of test pages and failed prints from the output area, and confirm the printer still appears correctly on every computer and phone that uses it. Ten quiet minutes a quarter is what keeps a shared household or office printer from becoming a source of recurring small crises.

One habit underlies all of this: change one thing at a time. When output disappoints, owners often swap paper, change settings, run cleaning and replace a supply in the same afternoon, and then cannot tell what fixed the problem or whether it is fixed at all. Methodical care feels slower and is faster, because the lesson from each fix carries into the next year of ownership instead of being lost.

Worked Examples: Three Buyers, Three Different Answers

Abstract advice only goes so far, so consider three households choosing between HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 and Brother MFC-L2820DW. Each reaches a defensible answer, and the answers differ, which is precisely the point: the better printer depends on the pattern of work it will be given.

The homework-and-forms household

Two school-age children, two working parents, a steady flow of worksheets, permission slips, return labels and the occasional color project. Volume is moderate but relentless, and almost all of it is time-sensitive: a form printed badly at night is a problem the next morning. For this household the deciding factors are reliability on plain paper, painless two-sided printing for handouts, and supplies that do not run out midweek. Either machine can do the work, so the choice turns on running-cost structure and on which control layout the parents find clearer when they are tired and in a hurry. The household should also weigh how each machine behaves after a quiet school holiday, because two idle weeks followed by a burst of printing is exactly the rhythm of family life.

The home office that clients see

A freelancer or small practice whose printed output reaches clients: proposals, invoices, signed agreements returned by scan. Here the scanner and the software around it matter as much as the print engine. Clean scans, sensible file naming, dependable copying of multi-page packets and a machine that looks and sounds composed on a desk all carry weight. Color needs are modest but visible, since a chart or a letterhead that prints muddy undermines the professional impression the documents are meant to create. This buyer should read the sections above on scanning and networking closely, and should think about what happens on the busiest day of the month rather than the average day, because a machine that copes with the average and fails at the peak fails when it matters most.

The occasional printer who hates waste

Some households print rarely: tickets, a tax return, a form, a few pages a month. Their enemy is not cost per page in the abstract but waste and decay between jobs: supplies that dry, clog or expire, machines that need coaxing back to life after every quiet month. For this buyer, the technology’s behavior during idle periods outweighs almost everything else, and the honest question is which of the two machines tolerates neglect better and recovers more gracefully when asked. This buyer should also consider whether printing at a library, a copy shop or an office would serve better than owning at all. Recommending against a purchase is sometimes the correct conclusion of a comparison, and a household that prints a handful of pages a month is the case where that conclusion deserves a fair hearing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which has lower running cost?

For black-and-white text, a laser usually costs less per page. Compare the supplies.

Which is better for a home office?

The 9125 if you need color; the Brother if you print mostly text.

Which one costs less to run?

Compare the replacement ink or toner price and page yield on each product page.

Can either print from my phone?

Most current printers support AirPrint, Mopria or an app. Check each product page.

What if I choose the wrong one?

Check the return window on Amazon and keep the packaging while you test it.

Can the Brother print in color?

No. It is a monochrome laser, so it prints in black and white. Use the HP inkjet or an outside service when color is required.

Does the HP need a phone line for fax?

Fax features generally need a phone line connection at the printer, though details vary. Check the manual for your setup.

Which is better for scanning many pages?

The Brother lists a 50-page feeder, while the HP also lists one. Check the product pages for feeder capacity and two-sided scanning support.

How do I compare running costs between ink and toner?

Divide each supply price by its stated page yield, remembering that yields are estimates and color costs differ. Use your real print mix to check the result.

Is an inkjet or laser better if I print rarely?

A laser is often less sensitive to idle periods, but check the maker's guidance for each model. With an inkjet, print occasionally to keep the heads in good condition.

Do both support Ethernet?

The Brother listing shows Ethernet, while the HP listing used here shows Wi-Fi. Check the HP product page for any wired option before you buy.

What should I do before selling or disposing of an old office printer?

Remove stored data and reset the printer to factory settings as the manual describes. Take out supplies and recycle them following the maker's instructions.

Is the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125 good for a small business?

It suits a small business that needs color documents along with fax, scanning and copying in one machine. Check the supply costs and the ink policy on the listing first. If most of your output is plain black text, a laser may fit better.

Is the Brother MFC-L2820DW worth it if I only print black and white?

It can be, because it is a monochrome laser built for text and it includes fax, scanning and a document feeder. It makes the most sense when color is not part of your work. Confirm the toner names and yields before you buy.

Can a laser printer print photos?

A monochrome laser such as the Brother prints in black and white only, so it cannot produce color photos. If photos matter, look at the HP inkjet and its supported photo papers. Check the listing for the details.

Do I need a landline to use the fax feature?

Fax generally needs a phone line connected to the printer, although the details depend on the model and your provider. Read the manual's fax section before setup. If you never send faxes, you can ignore this feature.

How often should I clean an office printer?

Wipe dust from the scanner glass and feeder when you see streaks, and follow the manual for any internal cleaning. Avoid running cleaning cycles on an inkjet unless print quality drops, since they use ink. Keeping paper dry and flat prevents many problems.

Why does my printer pull in several sheets at once?

Double feeds are usually caused by damp, stuck-together or overfilled paper. Fan the stack, reduce the amount loaded and check that the paper type matches the setting. If it continues, clean the rollers as the manual describes.

Is it better to buy a printer with Ethernet?

Ethernet is often steadier than Wi-Fi when several people share a printer. If your office has a wired network, a model with an Ethernet port is worth preferring. Check each listing for the connections it supports.

Should I buy extra ink or toner when I buy the printer?

Keep one spare of the supply you use most so a busy day is not interrupted. Do not overstock, since you should confirm yields and supply names first. Store spares flat and away from heat.

Bottom Line

Choose the 9125 for color and the MFC-L2820DW for monochrome speed. See best printers for working from home.

More Printer Guides