
The 5A is the most common drumstick size, a middle weight that sits between thin jazz sticks and heavy rock sticks. Most are hickory, and the real differences are tip shape, exact length and diameter, and how many pairs come in the pack.
The six sticks below cover a single-pair classic, a heat-tempered pair, multi-pair packs and a weight-matched natural set. Dimensions, tips and materials come from each product’s listing page. We have not used these sticks ourselves, and weight or pitch matching claims are the makers’ own.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links, and they do not change the product information we give.

What to Look For
| Feature | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Tip shape | Oval, teardrop and acorn tips change the sound on cymbals |
| Length and diameter | Small differences change balance and grip feel |
| Wood and finish | Lacquered, natural and heat-tempered hickory feel different |
| Pack size | One pair or several, so you can keep spares |
Specs at a Glance
| Sticks | Length and diameter | Tip | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vic Firth American Classic 5A | 16 in; 0.57 in listed | Teardrop | USA hickory; lacquer finish |
| ProMark Classic Forward 5A, 4 pairs | 16 in; 0.551 in | Oval wood | Hickory; made in the USA |
| ProMark Rebound 5A | 16 in; 0.565 in | Acorn | 3 hickory pairs plus 1 FireGrain pair |
| ProMark Classic Forward FireGrain | 16 in; 0.551 in | Oval wood | Heat-tempered hickory; 1 pair |
| Vater 5A | 16 in; 0.570 in | Wood | Maker says heavier toward the tip; 1 pair |
| HUN Bluefire 5A | 15.98 in; 0.563 in | Acorn | Natural finish; weight matched; 3 pairs |
The 6 Best 5A Drumsticks
1. Vic Firth American Classic 5A Drumsticks
A 16 inch 5A with a teardrop tip and a deep back-cut shape, made from USA hickory with a lacquer finish. The listing does not make clear how many pairs come in this version.
Suits: a familiar everyday 5A. Strengths: a well-known profile and a smooth lacquer finish. Weaknesses: the pack count is unclear on the page. Skip it if you want a multi-pair pack.
View Vic Firth American Classic 5A Drumsticks on Amazon
2. ProMark Classic Forward 5A Drumsticks, Wood Tip, 4 Pairs
Four pairs of 16 inch hickory sticks, 0.551 inches across, with an oval wood tip. The maker says its matching process keeps weight and pitch consistent from stick to stick and says they are made in Texas.
Suits: a drummer who wants spares on hand. Strengths: four pairs and a lacquer finish. Weaknesses: the matching claim is the maker’s own. Skip it if you only need one pair.
View ProMark Classic Forward 5A Drumsticks, Wood Tip, 4 Pairs on Amazon
3. ProMark Rebound 5A Hickory Drumsticks, Acorn Tip, 3 Pairs + 1 FireGrain 5A
A four-pair set of 16 inch sticks, 0.565 inches across, with an acorn tip the maker says gives a larger sweet spot. The fourth pair is made from FireGrain heat-tempered hickory.
Suits: a player who wants to compare two wood types. Strengths: an acorn tip and a mixed set. Weaknesses: a thicker diameter than the Classic Forward. Skip it if you want a slimmer stick.
View ProMark Rebound 5A Hickory Drumsticks, Acorn Tip, 3 Pairs + 1 FireGrain 5A on Amazon
4. ProMark Classic Forward FireGrain 5A Drumsticks Wood Tip
One pair of 16 inch FireGrain sticks, 0.551 inches across, with an oval wood tip. The maker describes a heat-tempering process meant to add durability and a controlled rebound.
Suits: a drummer curious about heat-tempered wood. Strengths: an oval tip and a slim diameter. Weaknesses: one pair only. Skip it if you want several pairs in the box.
View ProMark Classic Forward FireGrain 5A Drumsticks Wood Tip on Amazon
5. Vater 5A Hickory Drumsticks Pair, Wood Tip
A single pair listed as model VH5AW, 16 inches long and 0.570 inches across, with a wood tip. The listing calls the stick very well balanced and heavier toward the tip.
Suits: a tip-forward feel. Strengths: clear length and diameter figures. Weaknesses: a short listing with few details. Skip it if you want a spare pair included.
View Vater 5A Hickory Drumsticks Pair, Wood Tip on Amazon
6. HUN Bluefire Natural Color 5A Drumstick, 6 Sticks, Weight Matched
Three pairs of natural-finish American hickory sticks with no coating. The listing gives 15.98 inches by 0.563 inches, an acorn tip and weight matching to within 2 grams, all stated by the seller.
Suits: a natural, uncoated grip. Strengths: three pairs and an acorn tip. Weaknesses: a lesser-known brand and seller-stated figures. Skip it if you want a long-established maker.
View HUN Bluefire Natural Color 5A Drumstick,6 Sticks,Weight Matched on Amazon
Care and Setup
- Keep sticks dry and away from heat.
- Store them flat or in a stick bag.
- Rotate pairs so wear spreads evenly.
- Roll a stick on a flat surface to check for warp.
Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming every 5A feels the same.
- Ignoring tip shape when you want a certain cymbal sound.
- Buying one pair when you break sticks often.
- Leaving sticks in a hot car.
Drumsticks FAQ
What does 5A mean?
It is a common size code for a medium-weight, general-purpose stick. Exact dimensions vary by maker.
Do wood tips and nylon tips differ?
Yes. All six here use wood tips, which give a warmer attack than nylon on most cymbals.
Questions to Ask Before You Buy
- What style of music do you play most often, and how hard do you hit?
- Do you prefer a lighter stick for speed or a heavier one for power?
- Do you want a tip that suits cymbals, drums, or both?
- How quickly do you wear through a pair in a normal month?
- Do you practice on pads as well as a full kit?
- Is a matched pair important to you, or are small differences fine?
Matching It to Your Use
Beginners often do well with a middle-of-the-road size, since it feels natural in most hands. Players who gig regularly may want several pairs so a broken one never ends a session. If you teach, a bulk pack that can be handed to students is practical.
Wood type and finish change how a stick feels when sweaty hands grip it. Some players like a smooth surface; others prefer a coating that adds grip. Roll a stick on a flat surface in a shop if you can; a bent one will wobble.
Storage and Care Notes
Keep sticks in a dry case or bag, away from heat and damp. Wood can warp or dry out over time. Inspect them for splinters before playing, and retire ones with deep cracks. Rotate pairs so wear spreads evenly, and keep a spare pair in your gig bag. Follow the maker’s listing for any specific guidance. If you play in a humid room, a small pouch of moisture absorber in the case can help, and a case with a firm lining keeps tips from chipping against each other in transit.
Reading Size Codes Beyond 5A
The 5A in this guide is one point on a scale, and understanding the rest of the scale helps you decide whether it is the right place to start. Sizes use a number for diameter and a letter that traditionally pointed to the intended use. Lower numbers generally mean a thicker stick within a letter group, so a 7A is slimmer than a 5A, while a 2B is thicker than a 5B. Treat these as rough guides, because each maker draws the line a little differently.
A slimmer stick is lighter and quicker in the hand, which suits lighter playing, jazz and small rooms. A thicker stick has more mass, which many players find helpful for loud styles and for building stamina, though it can feel clumsy if your hands are small. The 5A sits in the middle, which is why it is a common first pair.
Do not rely on the label alone. The listings in this guide show actual lengths and diameters that differ by a few hundredths of an inch between models, and that is enough to change the balance. Compare the measurements on the product page, and if you already own a stick you like, match its length and diameter rather than only its code.
Tip Shape, Tip Material and What You Hear
The tip is the part that meets the cymbal and the head, so it shapes the sound more than most buyers expect. A small round or oval tip gives a defined, focused attack on a ride. A larger tip, such as an acorn or barrel shape, tends to give a broader, fuller wash and a bigger contact area. A teardrop sits somewhere between.
Tip material matters as well. Wood tips, which all the sticks here use, give a warmer, softer attack. Nylon tips are a different option you may see elsewhere, and they tend to sound brighter on cymbals and are less likely to chip, though they can loosen or wear with heavy use.
- Choose a smaller tip if you want clear stick definition on ride patterns.
- Choose a larger tip if you want a fuller sound and more forgiving contact.
- Check your cymbals: a bright, thin cymbal can sound harsh with a hard tip.
- Inspect tips regularly, since a chipped tip can scratch a cymbal and change the sound.
Because tip shape is easy to describe but hard to judge from a photo, buy one pair before a multi-pack if you are unsure.
Hickory, Maple, Oak and Heat Treatment
Hickory dominates the sticks in this guide because it balances strength, weight and shock absorption. Other woods exist, and each has a different character. Maple is generally lighter and softer, which suits lighter playing but may wear faster. Oak is usually denser and heavier. Check the listing for the wood species rather than assuming.
The finish affects grip. A lacquered stick feels smooth and can get slippery with sweaty hands. A natural, uncoated stick has a grippier feel that some players prefer, though it can pick up dirt and moisture. Some makers heat-treat their wood, as with the FireGrain pairs here, and describe it as adding durability and a controlled rebound. That is the makers’ claim, so judge it by how a pair holds up for you.
If you are comparing woods or finishes, change one variable at a time. A hickory pair in a smooth finish versus a hickory pair in a natural finish tells you more than switching wood, length and tip all at once. Keep notes on which pair felt best at the end of a long session, not only in the first five minutes.
Matching Sticks to Your Playing Style
The best stick depends on what you play and where. Practice at home on a pad, rehearsing in a small room and gigging in a loud band all ask different things from a stick. A general-purpose pair works for most beginners, but some situations call for a change.
- Light and quiet styles: a slimmer or lighter stick makes fast, delicate passages easier.
- Loud rock or marching-style work: a heavier stick adds weight but demands more from your wrists.
- Lessons and practice: a bulk pack covers broken sticks and lets you hand a pair to a student.
- Small hands or young players: a shorter, slimmer stick is easier to control.
Your grip also matters. If you play matched grip and use a lot of rebound, a stick with good balance near the middle will feel lively. If you push the stick toward the tip, a tip-heavy balance can feel natural. Try a few pairs over several sessions before committing to a case of them.
Signs a Pair Is Worn Out
Sticks wear down slowly, and many players keep using damaged ones past the point where they help. Retire a pair when the wood stops behaving predictably or becomes a safety issue.
- Splits or deep cracks along the shaft, which can fail suddenly and send splinters.
- A tip that has chipped or flattened unevenly, which changes the sound and can mark cymbals.
- A warped stick that wobbles when rolled on a flat surface.
- Heavy wear grooves where the stick hits rims or other sticks, which alter the balance.
- Pairs that no longer feel matched in weight or pitch when you tap them on a surface.
Rim shots and cross-stick playing wear sticks faster, so keep a spare in the bag if you play that way. If you notice you break sticks very often, consider a thicker model, since thin sticks break sooner under hard hitting, and review your technique with a teacher. Keep worn pairs separate for practice pad use so a failing stick never ends up in a live set.
Common Questions
Is a 5A good for a beginner?
Yes, it is a common first choice because the middle weight feels natural to most hands. If it feels too heavy or too thin after a few weeks, move one size up or down.
What is the difference between an oval and an acorn tip?
An oval tip has a smaller contact area and gives a more focused, defined sound on cymbals. An acorn tip is larger and tends to sound fuller. Check the tip shape on the listing before you buy.
Do natural and lacquered sticks sound different?
The finish mainly changes grip, not sound. Lacquer is smoother and a natural finish is grippier, so choose based on how your hands feel during a long session.
How many pairs should I buy at once?
If you break sticks often or teach, a multi-pair pack is practical. If you are still finding your preference, buy a single pair first and commit to a larger pack once you know what you like.
Can I use drumsticks on a practice pad and a full kit?
Yes, but pad practice wears tips faster. Many players keep a separate pair for the pad so the pairs used on cymbals stay in good shape.
How do I check a stick for warp?
Roll it on a flat surface such as a table or glass. A straight stick rolls smoothly, while a warped one wobbles or hops.
Does heat-tempered hickory last longer?
Makers describe heat treatment as adding durability, but how long a pair lasts depends on how hard and how often you play. Judge it by your own wear over time rather than by the claim alone.
Should my sticks match my cymbals?
It helps to think about it. Thin, bright cymbals can sound harsh with a hard tip, while larger tips tend to soften the attack. Try a pair on your own cymbals before buying in bulk.
The Short Version
For a familiar classic, the Vic Firth. For four pairs, the ProMark Classic Forward. For an acorn tip and a mixed set, the ProMark Rebound. For heat-tempered wood, the FireGrain. For a tip-forward balance, the Vater. For a natural uncoated set, the HUN Bluefire.